Salvation and Grace

Salvation and Grace

Catholic Outlook

Catholic Outlook

‍“So shall your offspring be”

‍How Was Abraham Justified?

‍What Abraham’s life reveals about justification by faith and works

Feather Pointed  Gary Hoge  ·  November 18, 2026

‍Protestants believe that we’re justified by faith alone. Catholics agree that our initial justification is a gift of God’s grace, received through faith, not something we can earn through good works.

‍So here’s a question: When was Abraham justified?

‍Most discussions of Abraham’s justification begin with Genesis 15:6, where Scripture tells us that Abraham believed God and that his faith was credited to him as righteousness. Paul quotes this passage in Romans 4 to demonstrate justification by faith.

‍But there’s something curious about that. Abraham had been believing God for years before Genesis 15. In fact, when the author of Hebrews sets out to celebrate Abraham’s faith, he begins with Genesis 12, when Abraham trusted God enough to leave his homeland without even knowing where he was going.

‍If justification is by faith alone, why wasn’t Abraham justified then?

‍Abraham’s faith in Genesis 12

‍Hebrews 11, sometimes called the “Faith Hall of Fame,” tells us:

‍By faith Abraham, when he was called, obeyed by going out to a place which he was to receive for an inheritance; and he went out, not knowing where he was going (Hebrews 11:8).

‍The event is recorded in Genesis 12. God told Abraham to leave his country and his relatives and travel to a land that God would show him. God promised to make him into a great nation and to bless him.

‍And Abraham believed God. He packed up his belongings and went.

‍Now, Hebrews doesn’t merely say that Abraham obeyed God. It specifically says he obeyed by faith. And just two verses earlier, Hebrews tells us that “without faith it is impossible to please God” (Hebrews 11:6).

‍So Abraham possessed the very faith that pleases God. Indeed, Hebrews 11:2 tells us that the people celebrated in that chapter gained God’s approval through their faith.

‍What was missing?

‍Did Abraham believe God, obey his call, and gain his approval, but somehow remain unjustified? Did his faith simply not “take” until Genesis 15, years later?

‍After all, it took extraordinary faith to uproot his entire life and head off to a land he’d never seen simply because God told him to. Believing God’s later promise of descendants certainly required faith, too, especially given Abraham’s age and Sarah’s barrenness. But what reason do we have to suppose that the faith Abraham exercised in Genesis 12 was somehow insufficient for justification?

‍Surely Abraham didn’t suddenly begin believing God in Genesis 15. He had been believing and obeying him for years.

‍In Genesis 12–14, we see Abraham walking in obedience to God. He builds altars and calls upon the name of the Lord. He trusts God’s promises, rescues his nephew Lot, and receives a blessing from Melchizedek, priest of God Most High, to whom he gives a tenth of everything.

‍All of these things happened before Genesis 15. Abraham was already living a life of faith.

‍Abraham’s justification in Genesis 15

‍Then, in Genesis 15, God promised Abraham that his descendants would be as numerous as the stars in the sky.

‍And Scripture tells us:

‍Abram believed the Lord, and he credited it to him as righteousness (Genesis 15:6).

‍This is the passage Paul quotes in Romans 4 when explaining justification by faith.

‍Paul was confronting the idea that righteousness could be obtained through observing the Mosaic Law. Circumcision was especially important to his argument because some Jewish Christians insisted that Gentile converts must be circumcised.

‍Paul wanted to show that justification is God’s gift, received through faith, not something we earn through our own efforts.

‍And Abraham was the perfect example.

‍Paul asks:

‍Is this blessedness only for the circumcised, or also for the uncircumcised? We have been saying that Abraham’s faith was credited to him as righteousness. Under what circumstances was it credited? Was it after he was circumcised, or before? It was not after, but before! (Romans 4:9–10).

‍Paul’s point is that Abraham was already righteous in God’s sight before he was circumcised. Therefore, circumcision couldn’t have been the means by which he obtained that righteousness.

‍But notice something else.

‍Paul doesn’t say that Genesis 15 was the first time Abraham was justified. He quotes Genesis 15:6 to establish that Abraham’s righteousness came through faith rather than circumcision.

‍And as we’ve already seen, Abraham had been exercising faith long before Genesis 15.

‍Calvin recognized the problem

‍Interestingly, the Protestant Reformer John Calvin recognized this very difficulty. Commenting on Genesis 15:6, Calvin wrote:

‍We are not here told when Abram first began to be justified, or to believe in God.1

‍Calvin understood that Abraham had already been living by faith for years. Genesis 15, he argued, wasn’t necessarily the moment Abraham first became justified. Rather, it illustrated the way Abraham had been justified throughout his life: through faith, not through the merit of his works.

‍Calvin nevertheless used this passage to defend his understanding of justification as the gracious imputation of righteousness through faith.

‍And that’s worth thinking about.

‍If Abraham was already justified before Genesis 15, then Genesis 15 cannot be used to establish when his initial justification occurred. Paul wasn’t identifying the moment Abraham first became righteous. He was explaining how Abraham was counted righteous before God.

‍But does Paul’s statement that Abraham’s faith was credited to him as righteousness mean that God merely declared him righteous without actually making him righteous? Does it establish that justification was completed forever at a single moment?

‍Paul doesn’t say either of those things.

‍His argument establishes that justification comes through faith rather than being earned through works. It doesn’t establish that the righteousness God gives us cannot subsequently increase.

‍And Abraham’s story doesn’t end in Genesis 15.

‍Abraham’s justification in Genesis 22

‍Many years later, God tested Abraham by commanding him to offer his son Isaac as a sacrifice. Abraham obeyed, although God intervened before Isaac was harmed.

‍James refers to this event when discussing the relationship between faith and works:

‍Was not Abraham our father justified by works, when he offered up Isaac his son on the altar? You see that faith was working with his works, and as a result of the works, faith was perfected (James 2:21–22).

‍And then James concludes:

‍You see that a man is justified by works, and not by faith alone (James 2:24).

‍Now we have something interesting.

‍Abraham exercised extraordinary faith in Genesis 12. His faith was credited to him as righteousness in Genesis 15. And many years later, James tells us that he was justified by works in Genesis 22.

‍How does that fit with the idea that justification is a single event, complete and perfect forever?

‍Was Abraham merely demonstrating his faith?

‍Protestants commonly explain James by saying that Abraham’s works didn’t actually contribute to his justification. They merely demonstrated that the faith by which he had already been justified was genuine.

‍In other words, Abraham was justified before God in Genesis 15, or perhaps earlier, and his obedience in Genesis 22 simply proved that he really had faith.

‍There’s certainly some truth in that explanation. Genuine faith does produce good works, and those works provide evidence that faith is real.

‍But is that all James is saying?

‍Look carefully at his words:

‍You see that faith was working with his works, and as a result of the works, faith was perfected (James 2:22).

‍James doesn’t merely say that Abraham’s works demonstrated his faith. He says that his faith was perfected by his works.

‍And then he adds:

‍And the Scripture was fulfilled which says, “And Abraham believed God, and it was reckoned to him as righteousness” (James 2:23).

‍That’s an interesting statement. James says that the Scripture concerning Abraham’s righteousness in Genesis 15 was fulfilled by what happened in Genesis 22. Abraham’s faith wasn’t merely displayed by his obedience. It was brought to completion through that obedience.

‍And James explicitly calls what happened in Genesis 22 justification.

‍Now, Protestants certainly agree that Abraham grew in holiness through his obedience. They simply call that growth sanctification rather than justification. And if James had said that Abraham was sanctified by works, there would be no disagreement. But that’s not what James said. He said Abraham was justified by works.

‍Calvin addressed this passage, too. He understood James to mean that Abraham’s righteousness was demonstrated or vindicated by his obedience, not that Abraham received an increase in justification.2

‍Protestants have a legitimate reason for interpreting James this way. Earlier in the chapter, James says that he will demonstrate his faith through his works (James 2:18). And the word justified can sometimes mean “shown to be righteous” or “vindicated.”

‍But that explanation has to account for everything James says—not merely that Abraham’s works revealed his faith, but that they perfected it and fulfilled the Scripture concerning his righteousness.

‍Those statements seem to describe something more than the outward demonstration of a justification completed years earlier. They suggest that Abraham’s obedience actually contributed to the growth and completion of his righteousness.

‍Paul and James are not contradicting each other

‍At first glance, Paul and James seem to disagree. Paul says that Abraham was justified by faith apart from works, while James says that Abraham was justified by works and not by faith alone.

‍But they’re addressing different questions.

‍Paul is explaining that justification comes from God’s grace, not from anything we can earn through our own efforts, whether by observing the Mosaic Law or performing good works.

‍James, on the other hand, is addressing people who already profess faith but think that faith can remain barren and inactive. He asks what good it is if someone claims to have faith but does nothing to help a brother or sister who lacks food or clothing (James 2:14–16).

‍His answer is that faith without works is dead.

‍Paul would agree. He repeatedly insists on the necessity of obedience and good works in the Christian life. He speaks of the “obedience of faith” (Romans 1:5), says that what counts is “faith working through love” (Galatians 5:6), and teaches that God will repay each person according to what he has done (Romans 2:6–7).

‍So Paul isn’t teaching that good works are irrelevant to salvation, and James isn’t teaching that we can earn our initial justification by performing them.

‍Paul explains why justification cannot be earned through works. James explains how the faith through which we are justified is brought to completion through works.

‍The two apostles aren’t contradicting each other. They’re describing different aspects of the same relationship with God.

‍Justification is more than a declaration

‍There’s another important difference between the Catholic and Protestant understandings of justification, although the two traditions agree on more than you might expect.

‍Both believe that justification begins with God’s grace, that we cannot earn it through good works, and that God actually transforms us inwardly, making us increasingly holy.

‍The disagreement concerns how that transformation relates to justification.

‍In classical Reformed Protestant theology, justification is a legal declaration. God declares the sinner righteous because Christ’s righteousness is credited to him. The believer’s subsequent growth in holiness is called sanctification. Although sanctification necessarily accompanies genuine justification, it doesn’t increase justification itself.

‍Catholics believe that justification includes both the forgiveness of sins and our interior renewal. When God justifies us, he doesn’t merely declare us righteous. He actually makes us righteous through his grace. And because that righteousness is something God produces within us, it can grow.

‍This doesn’t mean that we earn God’s grace or make ourselves righteous independently of him. Even our ability to perform good works comes from his grace. But when we cooperate with that grace, we really do grow in righteousness.

‍The Council of Trent expressed this by teaching that those who have already been justified can increase in the righteousness they have received through faith and good works.3

‍This distinction helps explain Abraham’s life.

‍His justification didn’t have to begin all over again each time he obeyed God. Nor did his obedience merely provide evidence of something that had been completed years earlier.

‍Rather, his faith grew, his obedience deepened, and his righteousness increased as he continued walking with God.

‍So when was Abraham justified?

‍Abraham’s story is particularly important because Scripture itself uses him to teach us about justification. Paul appeals to Abraham to explain justification by faith, and James appeals to the same man to explain justification by works. Catholics and Protestants alike look to Abraham to understand how God makes us righteous.

‍The Protestant interpretation isn’t impossible, or even unreasonable. There are legitimate biblical arguments for understanding James’s use of justified to mean “shown to be righteous.” But that interpretation has to account for more than James’s choice of words.

‍James tells us that Abraham’s faith was completed by his works and that the Scripture declaring him righteous was thereby fulfilled. Those statements suggest that Abraham’s obedience accomplished something in his relationship with God, rather than merely demonstrating a righteousness he already possessed.

‍The Catholic interpretation makes sense of all of this. Abraham was justified by faith, and as he continued to live and act in that faith, his righteousness increased. His faith was brought to completion through his works, just as James says.

‍The Protestant interpretation can accommodate these passages, but it requires additional explanations for why James describes Abraham’s later obedience in terms of justification, completion, and fulfillment.

‍I think the Catholic interpretation provides the simplest, most natural, and most coherent reading of both the biblical text and Abraham’s life as a whole.

‍__________

‍1 John Calvin, Commentary on Genesis, on Genesis 15:6.

‍2 John Calvin, Commentary on the Epistle of James, on James 2:21–24.

‍3 Council of Trent, Session VI (January 13, 1547), Decree on Justification, chapter 10, “On the Increase of Justification Received.” See also Catechism of the Catholic Church, paragraphs 1995 and 2010.