Scripture and Tradition
Scripture and Tradition
Catholic Outlook
Catholic Outlook
Does Scripture Alone Teach “Scripture Alone”?
Putting sola Scriptura to its own test
Part 1 of a four-part series testing the assumptions on which sola Scriptura rests
One of the central principles of Protestant Christianity is sola Scriptura, the belief that Scripture alone is the Church’s rule of faith and that every Christian doctrine must be established from Scripture.
For example, Faith Baptist Church, an independent Fundamentalist Baptist congregation, declares:
The Bible is our only authority for faith and practice (II Tim. 3:15–16). We reject the authority of tradition and church counsels.1
And Village Missions, an evangelical organization, makes the second part of that principle explicit:
Evangelical Christians assert that they get their doctrine exclusively from the Bible.2
Can sola Scriptura pass its own test?
If every Christian doctrine must be established from Scripture, what about sola Scriptura itself? Can “Scripture alone” be derived from Scripture alone?
You’re probably already thinking of some verses, aren’t you? Perhaps the Bereans in Acts 17? “Do not go beyond what is written” (1 Corinthians 4:6)? “All Scripture is God-breathed and is useful for teaching, rebuking, correcting and training in righteousness” (2 Timothy 3:16)?
But let’s step back and ask first whether it was even possible to rely on Scripture alone as a rule of faith when those verses were written.
According to Protestant apologist James White, it was not:
Protestants do not assert that sola scriptura is a valid concept during times of revelation. How could it be, since the rule of faith to which it points was at that very time coming into being? One must have an existing rule of faith to say it is “sufficient.” It is a canard to point to times of revelation and say, “See, sola scriptura doesn’t work there!” Of course it doesn’t. Who said it did?3
Ponder the implications of that for a moment.
Every New Testament document was written during the period when White says sola Scriptura was not “a valid concept” and “doesn’t work.” Every. Single. One.
So whatever verses you think teach sola Scriptura, they don’t. They can’t.
For example, when Paul told the Corinthians not to “go beyond what is written” (1 Corinthians 4:6), around A.D. 55, it’s likely that none of the four Gospels had been written yet, nor Acts, Romans, 2 Corinthians, most of Paul’s other letters, any of Peter’s or John’s letters, Hebrews, Jude, or Revelation.4
That’s a lot of Bible. And just because “Do not go beyond what is written” sounds like it affirms sola Scriptura, that doesn’t mean it even has anything to do with that topic. Read the verse in context. Paul was correcting the Corinthians for dividing into factions around different Christian teachers. He wasn’t establishing a rule of faith, and he certainly wasn’t telling them to rely on a collection of Scripture that mostly didn’t exist yet.
And the same is true of every other New Testament passage. None of them was teaching their audiences to practice a rule of faith that didn’t exist yet. But they were teaching something, something their original readers could understand and put into practice.
And what those passages taught then is what they still teach now. Their meaning doesn’t change with the passage of time. We can’t use them two thousand years later to make their authors say something they weren’t saying about a subject they weren’t addressing, just because their words sound like they support our position on some other topic.
So it’s a mistake to look through the New Testament books for a teaching that Scripture alone was supposed to be the rule of faith in the apostolic Church. That simply wasn’t possible while those books were still being written.
What, then, was the apostolic rule of faith? Paul tells us in 2 Thessalonians 2:15:
So then, brothers and sisters, stand firm and hold fast to the teachings we passed on to you, whether by word of mouth or by letter.
Christians were expected to hold fast to the teachings of the apostles, whether they wrote them down or not. That was the apostolic rule of faith, and it wasn’t sola Scriptura.
Does this disprove sola Scriptura once and for all?
Not necessarily. Sola Scriptura isn’t about what Christians were supposed to practice during the apostolic age, but what they were supposed to practice afterward.
It’s possible that the apostles intended Scripture alone to become the Church’s rule of faith at some point in the future, after divine revelation ended. That wouldn’t have contradicted the “by word of mouth or by letter” rule Christians were expected to follow during the apostolic age.
But if that’s what the apostles intended, where did they teach it?
As far as I know, the New Testament itself never even tells Christians that there should be a New Testament, much less that a new collection of inspired books—along with the Jewish Scriptures—should become the Church’s only rule of faith and practice at some point.
But these are the foundational premises on which sola Scriptura depends. So, by sola Scriptura’s own standard, shouldn’t they be taught somewhere in Scripture?
When could sola Scriptura have become the rule of faith?
Even if the apostles had intended Scripture alone to become the Church’s rule of faith after divine revelation ended, that wouldn’t have been possible right away.
The apostolic writings weren’t suddenly collected into a single volume and distributed to every Christian community when the last apostle died. They had to be copied and recopied by hand and carried from one Christian community to another, a process that took time. Some churches had access to writings that others didn’t.
And there was an even more fundamental problem. There were lots of writings circulating among Christians in the decades after the last apostle died. They had to determine which of those writings were inspired Scripture, and which were not.
Some books were widely accepted from an early date, but others remained disputed well into the fourth century. It wasn’t until A.D. 367 that we find the first surviving list containing precisely the 27 books of our present New Testament, in a letter written by Athanasius, bishop of Alexandria.5 Even then, universal agreement didn’t immediately follow.
James White pointed out that sola Scriptura couldn’t have been the rule of faith while Scripture was still being written. And he’s right. But the same reasoning that applies to the writing of Scripture also applies to its recognition as Scripture. The Church’s rule of faith couldn’t have been Scripture alone while Christians were still trying to figure out what alone constituted Scripture.
So as a practical matter, sola Scriptura couldn’t have become the Church’s rule of faith before the late fourth century at the earliest, when Christians were finally beginning to reach a broader agreement about which books belonged in the New Testament.
Conclusion
We began by asking whether sola Scriptura can pass its own test. If every Christian doctrine must be established from Scripture, then sola Scriptura itself must be established from Scripture.
But we’ve seen that sola Scriptura couldn’t have been practiced during the apostolic age. Therefore, none of the New Testament writings could have taught it as an apostolic practice. Nor does Scripture teach that the Church was supposed to abandon the apostolic rule of faith and replace it with Scripture alone at some point in the future.
So the fact that the New Testament doesn’t teach sola Scriptura as an apostolic practice or as a future rule shows that “Scripture alone” can’t be established from Scripture alone, and sola Scriptura fails its own test.
And that’s a good thing!
Ironically, by rejecting sola Scriptura we honor Scripture more, not less. Instead of forcing it into a role its authors never envisioned and for which it is ill-equipped, we allow it to fulfill the purpose God intended for it—a purpose for which it is perfectly suited.
God intended Scripture to convey truth, to reveal Jesus Christ and his saving work, to nourish the spiritual life, to equip us for good works, and to serve as a source for prayer, preaching, worship, and education. It was never meant to be a blueprint for reconstructing Christianity from scratch.
The apostles didn’t teach Christians through their writings alone. They taught the faith in person, too, and instructed Christians to preserve and pass on what they’d received, whether orally or in writing (2 Thessalonians 2:15; 2 Timothy 2:2).
That was the rule of faith in the apostolic Church, and it’s the rule of faith the Church still follows today.
There’s something liberating about reading Scripture in that context. After all, the New Testament was written to people who were already Christians, who had already learned their faith from the apostles and those who taught in their name. Its authors could take that knowledge for granted, without having to explain everything all over again.
When we read their writings in the light of that same faith, preserved and passed down through the Church, the pieces begin to fit together. Scripture becomes part of a unified whole. We no longer have to approach it as if we’re encountering Christianity for the first time or press it for answers to questions it wasn’t addressing.
So perhaps it’s a good thing that Scripture doesn’t teach us to rely on Scripture alone. Freed from that expectation, we can read the Bible within the faith the apostles handed down, allowing it to speak to us as it spoke to the Christians who read it first.
In this series:
1. Does Scripture Alone Teach “Scripture Alone”? — Biblical basis
2. Does the New Testament Contain Everything We Need to Know? — Completeness
3. Why Can’t We Agree on the Clear Teachings of Scripture? — Clarity
4. Who Has the Final Say When Christians Disagree? — Who settles disputes?
__________
1 Faith Baptist Church, “Our Distinctives.” Under “The Bible,” the church describes Scripture as its only authority for faith and practice and rejects the authority of church councils and tradition.
2 Village Missions, Contenders Discipleship Initiative: Doctrine Instructor’s Guide, “Where Doctrines Originate.” The guide states, “Evangelical Christians assert that they get their doctrine exclusively from the Bible.”
3 James R. White, “A Review and Rebuttal of Steve Ray’s Article, ‘Why the Bereans Rejected Sola Scriptura.’” Alpha and Omega Ministries, April 29, 1998.
4 Bible Gateway, “When Was the Bible Written?” Approximate dates for the New Testament writings. See also Crossway, “Where, When, and Why Were Each of Paul’s Letters Written?”.
5 Athanasius of Alexandria, Thirty-Ninth Festal Letter (A.D. 367), sections 5–7. Athanasius lists precisely the 27 books of the present New Testament.
Featured Articles
Copyright © 2024–[YEAR] Catholicoutlook.me