Faith and Reason
Faith and Reason
Catholic Outlook
Catholic Outlook
The History of the Heavens
How we discovered that Earth moves
Once Greek thinkers realized that Earth was spherical (by about 500 BC), most astronomers assumed that it was stationary and that the objects they saw in the sky revolved around Earth once each day. That makes sense, because it’s what we seem to observe. We can’t feel Earth move, so it makes sense to assume that it doesn’t. Likewise, we can see the objects in the sky move with our own eyes, so it makes sense to assume that they actually do move.
For most of us, of course, none of this makes much practical difference. Sherlock Holmes famously told Dr. Watson, “You say that we go round the sun. If we went round the moon it would not make a pennyworth of difference to me or to my work.” Holmes may not have cared, but astronomers did. And over the centuries they became very good at figuring out what was actually moving around what.
Explaining the sky
One of the first things they noticed was that five of the stars in the night sky moved relative to the other stars. They called them “planets,” from the Greek word πλανήτης (planētēs), meaning “wanderer.” But unlike the fixed stars, the planets didn’t move across the sky in a steady, uniform way. They usually moved eastward, but sometimes they would slow down and stop, then actually move westward for a time before stopping again and resuming their eastward motion. The fancy name for this phenomenon is “retrograde motion.”
In the second century, Greco-Egyptian astronomer Claudius Ptolemy came up with a model of the solar system in which the Sun, Moon, planets, and stars all revolve around a stationary Earth. Among the devices Ptolemy used to account for the observed retrograde motion of the planets were small circles called epicycles. He proposed that the planets moved along these small circles as the epicycles themselves moved along much larger circles (called deferents) around Earth.
This model fit the observed motion of the celestial bodies, but it required an elaborate geometrical framework to do so.
In the 16th century, Polish astronomer Nicolaus Copernicus became dissatisfied with the Ptolemaic system and sought a more coherent geometrical arrangement of the heavens. Like Ptolemy, he assumed that celestial motions were composed of uniform circular motions, but he placed the Sun near the center and made Earth one of the planets. In 1543, just before his death, he proposed a model in which all the planets, including Earth, orbited the Sun. He also proposed that the apparent daily rotation of the heavens could be explained more simply if the heavens were stationary and Earth itself were rotating in the opposite direction.
His model had the advantage of providing a more unified explanation for several puzzling features of planetary motion. In his model, retrograde motion was an apparent reversal of direction caused by Earth either passing or being passed by the other planets as they moved around the Sun. It also accounted for the fact that the inner planets Mercury and Venus never strayed far from the Sun.
The Danish astronomer Tycho Brahe was impressed by aspects of the Copernican system, but he thought Earth was too big, too heavy, and too sluggish to be capable of the motion that Copernicus proposed. He also reasoned that if Earth were orbiting the Sun, we should be able to observe a slight shift in the nearby stars relative to more distant stars, a phenomenon called “stellar parallax.” Because Tycho wasn’t able to observe stellar parallax, he concluded that Copernicus was wrong about Earth orbiting the Sun.
So, in 1588 Tycho proposed a model of the solar system in which all of the planets except Earth orbit the Sun, while the Sun orbits a stationary Earth. The Tychonic model preserved the mathematical elegance of the Copernican model while also preserving a stationary Earth.
Galileo champions the Copernican model
In 1609, after the death of Tycho and after the invention of the telescope, Italian astronomer Galileo Galilei began studying the night sky with a telescope. The following year, his observations of the phases of Venus demonstrated that Venus must travel around the Sun rather than around Earth in the manner required by the traditional Ptolemaic model. That disproved the Ptolemaic arrangement, leaving the Copernican and Tychonic systems as the two major viable alternatives.
Galileo favored the Copernican model with its rotating, Sun-orbiting Earth to the Tychonic system with its stationary Earth and rotating universe. But for all his bluster (and Galileo had a lot of bluster), he couldn’t come up with decisive proof that Earth was moving and that the Copernican model was correct.
He suggested that the combination of Earth’s rotation about its axis and its revolution around the Sun caused parts of Earth’s surface to speed up and slow down, making the oceans slosh around like water in a bathtub and producing the tides we observe every day. But that theory was wrong, and it predicted only one high tide each day rather than accounting for the roughly twice-daily tidal cycle commonly observed.
German astronomer Johannes Kepler, who had been Tycho’s assistant, recognized a relationship between the Moon and the tides, and correctly suspected that the Moon exerted some sort of influence on Earth’s oceans. This was 70 years before Newton proposed his law of universal gravitation, so it’s understandable that Galileo was skeptical that the Moon could affect Earth’s oceans in this way. He praised Kepler as an exceptional thinker, but ridiculed his lunar theory of the tides as an “occult” and childish idea.1
The Copernican model wins out
It was actually Kepler, not Galileo, who began to turn the tide in favor of the Copernican model. Like other astronomers of his time, Copernicus assumed that planetary motions were composed of perfect circles. But Kepler discovered that the planets actually follow elliptical orbits, with the Sun at one focus of the ellipse. He also discovered that the planets moved faster as they got closer to the Sun, and slower as they got farther away from it. These two observations (known as Kepler’s first and second laws) suggested that the Sun was somehow responsible for planetary motion.
It was still possible to construct a mathematical model along the lines of the Tychonic model that accommodated Kepler’s observations, but the resulting physical picture became increasingly difficult to justify: the five visible planets had their motions arranged around the Sun, while Earth alone was treated differently. It seemed more likely that the solar system was Sun-centered (“heliocentric”) and not Earth-centered (“geocentric”).
Newton provides the physical explanation
The major breakthrough that supplied a physical basis for the Copernican system came in 1687, when Isaac Newton published Philosophiæ Naturalis Principia Mathematica (Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy). Newton showed that the same simple laws of motion and gravitation could account for all manner of observed motion, including falling objects on Earth, the Moon’s orbit, the planets’ orbits, the motion of comets, and Kepler’s laws.
Newton also showed that gravitating bodies move around their common center of mass. Because the Sun contains about 99.86 percent of the solar system’s mass, the solar system’s center of mass lies in or near the Sun. Newton’s laws therefore provided a physical explanation for why Earth and the other planets orbit the Sun, without requiring Earth to occupy a special, stationary position.
James Bradley demonstrates that Earth is moving through space
With improvements in scientific instruments, direct observational confirmation of heliocentrism quickly followed. Just 40 years after Newton published the Principia, in 1727–28 English astronomer (and Anglican priest) James Bradley, who was trying to measure stellar parallax, accidentally discovered the phenomenon of stellar aberration.
An analogy is helpful to understand stellar aberration. Imagine that you’re standing in the rain on a windless day. The raindrops are falling straight down, so you have to hold your umbrella directly over your head to stay dry. Now imagine that you start running. The raindrops are still falling straight down, but from your point of view they seem to come at you diagonally. You have to tilt your umbrella in the direction you’re moving in order to stay dry. That’s roughly analogous to how stellar aberration works.
Suppose a star is directly overhead. Its light is traveling toward Earth at about 300,000 km/s. But Earth itself is moving sideways in its orbit at about 30 km/s, carrying you and your telescope with it. Consequently, from the moving Earth’s frame of reference, the incoming light appears to arrive at a very slightly different angle—just as vertically falling rain appears to come toward a running person at an angle.
You therefore have to point the telescope very slightly in the direction of Earth’s motion to center the star. The angle is tiny because light travels about 10,000 times faster than Earth orbits the Sun.
Six months later, Earth is on the opposite side of the Sun and traveling in approximately the opposite direction, so the direction in which the telescope has to be tilted changes over the course of the year. A star consequently appears to trace a tiny annual pattern in the sky.
That annual variation is what Bradley discovered. His accidental discovery of stellar aberration provided direct observational evidence that Earth was moving through space.
Friedrich Bessel demonstrates that Earth orbits the Sun
Tycho Brahe, Nicolaus Copernicus, and even the ancient Greek astronomer Aristarchus of Samos predicted that if Earth were orbiting the Sun, a nearby star should appear to shift slightly relative to more distant stars as Earth moved around the Sun. The fact that they weren’t able to observe such apparent motion was taken as evidence against heliocentrism.
Copernicus theorized that perhaps the stars were so incredibly distant that their parallax was too small to detect. He turned out to be right. In 1837–1838, German astronomer Friedrich Bessel studied the star 61 Cygni with a Fraunhofer heliometer.2 Bessel hoped to observe a small back-and-forth displacement in the star’s apparent position that repeated in sync with Earth’s position around the Sun.
Bessel succeeded, finally providing a direct geometrical demonstration of Earth’s orbit around the Sun, something astronomers had sought unsuccessfully for centuries. Bessel was able to measure a parallax of approximately 0.314 arcseconds, confirming Copernicus’ supposition that the stars were so distant that their parallax was too small for earlier astronomers to detect. This demonstrated that Earth was not only moving through space, but orbiting the Sun.
Léon Foucault demonstrates that Earth rotates
The successful measurements of stellar aberration and stellar parallax provided direct observational demonstrations that Earth moves through space and orbits the Sun. In 1851 Léon Foucault demonstrated that Earth also rotates on its axis. He did that by hanging a heavy pendulum from a long wire and making it swing back and forth. His public demonstration at the Panthéon in Paris used a wire about 220 feet long and a 62-pound weight.
Once the pendulum was swinging freely, its plane of oscillation tended to maintain its orientation while Earth rotated beneath it. Foucault arranged a series of marks on the floor. As time passed, the pendulum’s path shifted relative to those marks, revealing Earth’s rotation.
This was the first simple, direct demonstration that Earth rotates. The observed effect varies predictably with the latitude at which the experiment is performed. As expected, the plane of the pendulum’s swing doesn’t rotate relative to the ground at the equator, and its apparent rate of rotation increases with latitude. At the poles the effect is most pronounced, with the plane of oscillation completing a full rotation relative to the ground in approximately 24 hours.
A modern confirmation of Earth’s rotation
The advent of rocketry provided a striking new demonstration of the consequences of Earth’s rotation, one that wasn’t available to scientists in previous centuries. If Earth were rotating and an artificial satellite were placed in a circular orbit over the equator, moving in the same direction as Earth’s rotation and completing one orbit in the same time Earth takes to rotate once, the satellite would remain over the same point on Earth’s surface. Such an orbit is called “geostationary.”
In October 1945, British science-fiction writer Arthur C. Clarke published an article titled “Extra-Terrestrial Relays” in the British electronics magazine Wireless World. Clarke envisioned a network of three unmanned communication satellites placed in geostationary orbit and equidistantly spaced around the world. In such a network, each satellite would always be able to “see” the other two, and so television and radio could be broadcast all over the inhabited world.
Clarke’s vision began to become a practical reality with the development of geostationary communications satellites in the 1960s. Today, these satellites operate exactly as predicted by Newtonian mechanics: they remain above the same locations on Earth because their orbital motion matches Earth’s rotation. The geostationary orbital band is sometimes called the “Clarke Belt” in Clarke’s honor.
Conclusion
Our understanding of the universe began with the reasonable assumption that our senses were giving us an accurate perception of it. It appeared that the solid Earth under our feet did not move, and the objects we saw in the sky did. But there were things that were difficult to explain, like the retrograde motion of the planets. And just because Earth felt like it wasn’t moving didn’t mean it wasn’t. Our bodies can sense acceleration, but not steady motion. If you close your eyes when you’re in an airliner that’s not accelerating, you can’t tell you’re moving.
Copernicus showed that putting Earth in motion around the Sun provided a more coherent explanation of what astronomers observed in the heavens. Kepler’s discoveries provided further evidence that the planets revolved around the Sun, and Newton explained why they did. Then Bradley, Bessel, and Foucault provided increasingly direct evidence that Earth moves through space, orbits the Sun, and rotates on its axis. Today, geostationary satellites provide a striking practical confirmation of that rotation.
That’s how we came to know—and demonstrate—that Earth moves through space, orbits the Sun, and rotates on its axis.
__________
1 Galileo Galilei, Dialogue Concerning the Two Chief World Systems, Fourth Day (1632), trans. Stillman Drake.
2 A Fraunhofer heliometer was a 19th-century refracting telescope with a split objective lens, designed by German physicist and optician Joseph von Fraunhofer to measure tiny angular distances between stars with extreme precision.
Figure 1: The Ptolemaic System
Figure 2: The Copernican System
Figure 3: The Tychonic System
Figure 4: Stellar Aberration
Figure 5: Stellar Parallax
Figure 6: Foucault Pendulum
Figure 7: Geostationary Satellites
Featured Articles
Archive
Copyright © 2024–[YEAR] Catholicoutlook.me